← Back to blog

PNG, JPG, WebP, AVIF, JPEG XL, GIF or APNG? Choosing an Image Format Without the Jargon

Four questions settle almost every image-format choice: transparency, motion, size versus exactness, and who has to open the file. Then convert in your browser with Sakarto.

What you’ll learn in this post:

  • The four questions that decide which format to use
  • What lossy and lossless really mean for your files
  • A side-by-side table of all seven formats
  • Which conversion to run for the most common situations

Most people never choose an image format. The camera, the screenshot tool or the website chooses for them, and the problem only appears later: the file is too big, won’t upload, won’t open, or has a black box where the transparency used to be.

You don’t need to memorise how each codec works. You need four questions, asked in order.


The four questions

1. Does it need transparency?

If yes, rule out JPG: a JPG is always a full rectangle. PNG, WebP, AVIF, JPEG XL and APNG keep smooth, see-through edges. GIF can only make a pixel fully transparent or fully solid, so soft shadows end up jagged.

2. Does it move?

For animation you can use WebP, AVIF, JPEG XL, APNG or GIF. GIF is the most compatible and the heaviest. A plain PNG or JPG holds a single picture.

3. Do you want the smallest file or the exact pixels?

  • Lossy formats throw away detail your eye is unlikely to miss, giving the smallest files. Each lossy re-save loses a little more.
  • Lossless formats keep every pixel exactly, so you can save again and again without degrading anything. The price is a bigger file.

WebP, AVIF and JPEG XL can do both. JPG is lossy only; PNG, GIF and APNG are lossless (GIF within a 256-colour palette).

4. Who has to open it?

JPG, PNG and GIF open almost everywhere. WebP, AVIF and APNG suit modern browsers. JPEG XL has the fewest viewers, and many editors, phone galleries and web forms won’t recognise it.


All seven side by side

FormatCompressionTransparencyAnimationTypical useSupport
PNGLosslessβœ“ Fullβ€” Not in plain PNGScreenshots, logos, graphicsβœ“ Everywhere
JPGLossyβ€” Noneβ€”Photographsβœ“ Everywhere
WebPLossy or losslessβœ“ Fullβœ“ YesWebsites and appsβœ“ Modern browsers
AVIFLossy or losslessβœ“ Fullβœ“ YesSmallest web imagesβœ“ Modern browsers
JPEG XLLossy or losslessβœ“ Fullβœ“ YesHigh-quality archives⚠ Limited viewers
GIFLossless, 256 colours⚠ On or offβœ“ YesLegacy animationsβœ“ Everywhere
APNGLosslessβœ“ Fullβœ“ YesAnimated graphicsβœ“ Modern browsers

Situations, and the conversion that fits

SituationConvertWhy
Website logo or UI graphic that needs transparency and a lighter downloadPNG β†’ WebPWebP keeps transparency and is widely supported
Large hero images where every kilobyte counts, modern browsers onlyPNG β†’ AVIF or JPG β†’ AVIFAVIF usually gives the smallest files, but encodes more slowly
A screenshot of a photo saved as PNGPNG β†’ JPGPNG can be several times bigger than JPG for photographic content; choose a background colour for any transparent areas
A photo you plan to edit many timesJPG β†’ PNGA lossless working copy stops further loss (it doesn’t restore detail)
Archiving PNGs in less space with identical pixelsPNG β†’ JPEG XL (lossless)Lossless JPEG XL is typically much smaller than the PNG
A web image your editor or messenger refusesWebP β†’ PNG or WebP β†’ JPGThe most compatible answers
An .avif that older software can’t openAVIF β†’ JPG or AVIF β†’ PNGJPG for sharing, PNG for a copy that never loses quality
A .jxl to send to someoneJPEG XL β†’ JPGJPG opens on practically everything
βœ…
Every one of these runs in your browser. Sakarto's 42 converters decode and encode your pictures on your own device. Nothing is uploaded.

Common mistakes

  • Expecting a conversion to sharpen a picture. A conversion can’t bring back colours or detail the source format already threw away. JPG β†’ PNG simply freezes the JPG as it is today.
  • Converting lossy to lossy repeatedly. Every lossy save adds a little loss. Keep your best copy and make smaller versions from it.
  • Using GIF for photos. A 256-colour palette bands skies and skin tones. Use GIF only where it is required, and try dithering to soften banding.
  • Replacing originals with a format your audience can’t open. Keep the original, convert a copy, and check it in the app where it will be used.
  • Forgetting the background. A transparent PNG has no colour of its own. Going to JPG forces you to choose one, and a mismatched choice shows up as a halo.

A sensible default setup

If you just want rules of thumb:

  1. Archive masters you will edit: PNG (or lossless JPEG XL if your tools support it).
  2. Photos for the web: WebP for broad support, AVIF where you only care about modern browsers and small size.
  3. Anything that must open anywhere: JPG for photos, PNG for graphics.
  4. Animation: animated WebP or AVIF for the web, GIF only where nothing else is accepted. The animated-image guide covers this in depth.

The verdict

Four questions (transparency, motion, size versus exactness, audience) settle almost every choice. When the answer is β€œI picked wrong,” conversion is cheap, as long as you start from the best copy you have and keep the original. Each of the seven formats has its own converter page with the six conversions that make sense for it:

PNG Β· JPG Β· WebP Β· AVIF Β· JPEG XL Β· GIF Β· APNG


Ready to convert?

November 4, 2026
⏱ 6 min read
πŸ‡¬πŸ‡§ English